by Ruth Popp | Spring 2017
A new college test, and why it’s important
A BETTER COLLEGE ADMISSIONS TEST EMERGES
The word “Classic” in the CLT name refers to ideas that have stood the test of time. As the SAT and ACT scramble to remain relevant, this new exam has emerged with a clear vision to reconnect students with the virtue, ethics, and intellectual inheritance of the Western tradition. The descriptors of the CLT test read like advertisements for classical education. The high scorer in each of the three official test cycles to date have been classically educated students.
Students should be helped by their families, communities, and schools to achieve their highest possible levels of knowledge and understanding, to live a rich life undergirded by the greatest ideas, and to be taught virtue, the greatest source of satisfaction. This is why Aristotle famously said, “Educating the mind without educating the heart is no education at all.”
WHAT WENT WRONG WITH THE SAT & ACT?
David Coleman was the “chief architect” of the Common Core Standards—the reengineering of national scholastic standards and, by ripple effect, the curriculum often chosen for the classroom. Now Coleman presides over the newly redesigned SAT, which measures the effectiveness of his earlier project.
On September 22, 2016, Coleman spoke at the National Association for College Admission Counseling conference. In the educational breakout session, “A Conversation with David Coleman,” he shed light on the core values underlying the new SAT.
“The revision of the SAT has gotten rid entirely of every vestige, every remainder of the notion that it is an aptitude test … The New SAT is entirely an achievement test.”
Coleman stated clearly that the SAT no longer measures aptitude. It is an achievement test—a measure of the content retained after a particular course of study. To which course of study does Coleman refer? Since the Common Core Standards have come under intense fire from dissatisfied parents and educators across the country, both the SAT and ACT have flushed any reference to the Common Core Standards from their websites, but they are certainly implied by the phrase “what students learn in class,” a phrase used to describe the content on the SAT. Remember, Coleman was the architect of the Common Core before he took over the SAT.
“Should an exam they take to get into college be different from the work they do in high school? No, it must not be. It should be exactly the same.”
According to Coleman, it is no longer fair to ask students to do more than recite facts and ideas they have previously studied. What does “exactly the same” look like? Coleman assures us the new SAT has no “puzzle like questions, tricky things, things that try to surprise and be different than what you’ve done in the classroom.” Coleman described the material appearing in the math section as “elegant, brief problems that are clear to students, that allow them to show their math knowledge easily, that are easily accessible to them. Every extra word should go. Complex distracting situations should go.”
Clearly, the Common Core Standards and the new SAT do not expect students to apply their abilities or knowledge in any new or adaptive way. Coleman affirmed that the new SAT would be easier than the old SAT, cutting 70 questions while allowing the same time for completion.
“Why did we get rid of obscure vocabulary words? … Imagine what those words were like for English language learners … It is time for the SAT to be an exam for our most vulnerable students … ”
With this statement Coleman reveals the shift that drives every change. The College Board’s mission is not to measure the quality or rigor of education, but rather to compromise quality in whatever way necessary to improve equality of access to higher education.
Why is it necessary to lower the standard? The answers suggest acceptance of the idea that the primary objective of education in the U.S. is to be fair to underserved, at-risk populations and equalize opportunity. Coleman tells us it would be unfair to ask students to think critically, to problem-solve through complexity, to identify and eliminate distractors, to test themselves against the higher standards they will encounter as college freshmen.
These lower standards will creep into high schools and below, as parents and educators demand their students be put in front of the kind of low-complexity, basic vocabulary selections featured on the SAT and ACT.
WHAT CAN WE DO?
Unite. When thousands of the most highly sought after students register for the CLT exam, more colleges will accept the exam results. When more students read the enduring literature and documents of Western civilization, the moral and civic foundation of the coming generations will be strengthened. We have the power to drive the change. When we stand together, our voices will be heard.
THE MORAL DEBATE
When students sit for the cumulative exam of twelve years of academic preparation, its content sends a powerful message. It has been argued that both the SAT and ACT are important cogs in a machine that perpetuates the philosophy of “value neutral” education.
Many educators bleach out the values inherent in any discussion of depth concerning historical, literary, and scientific endeavor in order to prepare students for a standardized test, requiring only a regurgitation of disconnected facts, or the careful presentation of a “value neutral” argument.
Truth, goodness, and beauty are sacrificed daily at the altar of moral relativism. Once students have accepted the idea that truth does not exist, they have been crippled in their ability to recognize and respond to the One who is Truth.
WHY DOES THIS MATTER?
Our children will work shoulder to shoulder with their peers to secure the blessings of liberty for the next generation. What other students learn will impact their lives and future for better, or worse.
A Better Measure of Success
A Better Admissions Test: Raising the Standard for College Entrance Exams, consolidates concerns that the SAT and ACT rise from a disordered understanding of what it means to be educated. This timely book offers the wisdom of current and former headmasters, professors, and college presidents daring to question the status quo and envision a solid alternative.
A Perfect Challenge
The elusive perfect score, 120, has yet to be achieved. The first student to ace the CLT will receive a full, four- year, tuition, room and board scholarship to any school in the United States to which they gain admission. SEE CLTEXAM.COM
1 David Coleman, “A Conversation with David Coleman” (Education- al breakout session, National Association for College Admission Coun- seling (NACAC) conference, Columbus, Ohio, September 22, 2016)
RUTH POPP earned a B.S. from the United States Naval Academy. Personal growth as an educator led her to the classical education renewal gaining strength across the nation. She currently serves as director and president of the Board for St. Thomas Aquinas Tutorial in Millersville, MD, and on the Board of Academic Advisors for Classic Learning Initiatives. Ruth has 5 daughters.